First of all, it should be clear that a pilgrim has to follow the guidance of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) when offering Hajj or `Umrah, for it’s the Prophet’s command for Muslims to take their rituals from him. Violations should be avoided as much as possible. Sheikh Sayyed Sabiq states in his well-known book, Fiqh As-Sunnah
“For Sa`i to be valid and acceptable, it must meet the following conditions:
1- It should be performed after Tawaf (circumambulation of the Ka`bah).
2- It must be performed in seven rounds.
3- It must begin from Safa and end at Marwah.
4- It must be performed in Al-Mas`a, the path between Safa and Marwah, because the Prophet (peace be and blessings upon him) did so, and moreover he explicitly told us: “Take your (religious) rites from me.” Therefore, a Sa`i performed without performing Tawaf prior to it, or one that starts from Marwah and ends at Safa, or is performed in a place other than the specified area, is void. However, the Hanafi school holds that Sa`i after Tawaf and starting it at Safa and ending it at Marwah are two essential conditions for the validity of Hajj. Thus if someone makes a Sa`i before making Tawaf, or starts his Sa`i at Marwah and ends it at Safa, his Sa`i is valid, but he is required to slaughter an animal.”
Based on the above facts, it becomes clear that Sa`i that starts at Marwah and ends at Safa is void according to some scholars, while others say that it’s valid but requires the slaughter of an animal. A Muslim is highly recommended to follow the suit of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) so as to achieve success in this world and the world to come.
Starting Sa`i from Marwah: Is Hajj Valid?
Did you like this content?
Recommended
`Eid: Etiquette & Rulings
Making up for Missed Fasting Days in Shawwal
Rulings on eating before eid al fitr and changing of route
Visiting Graves on the Day of `Eid
Infusing Vigor into the Muslim Ummah After Ramadan
Is Fasting Six Days of Shawwal Mandatory?
Shortening and Combining Prayers
How to overcome waswasah
Solar & Lunar Eclipses: A Muslim Perspective
How to attain Jannat Al-Firdaws
Top Reading