Respected scholars,as-salamu `alaykum. What should a Muslim do with regard to scholarly differences concerning whether a hadith is authentic or unauthentic? Jazakum Allahu Khayran.
There are so many scholars how do we know which opinion to follow? Do we have to pick one scholar? If we do pick one do we have to know what that particular scholar's opinion is regarding all everyday issues or can we read a book or do what the masses do?
Respected scholars, as-salamu `alaykum.I am an imam in the US, and I am facing problems with the Muslim community here because when I do something, some seem to like it and others seem to dislike it. The community here follows different madhhabs [schools of thought] and sects, and some people are very critical to everything that is different from the madhhab they follow. Please advise me as to what can be done in this problematic situation.Jazakum Allahu Khayran.
Respected scholard, assalamu-alia kum.My question relates to the idea that in today's Muslim world, there seems to be a range of interpretations of the Islamic religion.We see both what could be considered "moderate" and "extreme" implementations of Islam around the world. In the eyes of many non-Muslims I know, this range of views is extensive, and leads to the idea that Islam and the Quran is open to interpretation.For example, we see in some communities women are forced to cover their entire bodies, and are unfortunately treated badly. Whereas in other communities, women are treated closer to what the Quran asks of us, and as equals.Another example of course is the Taliban, and their very "extreme" interpretations of the Quran, leading to many well known beliefs which most people would say acts against Islam.Why is it there appears to be such a range of views? Or is it your opinion this idea is highly exagerated, owing to how we view our world through the media?Thank you, and peace be with you.Odai.